Best Cash Home Buying Companies in Long Island 2025 — Why Square One is #1
Best cash home buying companies in Long Island 2025 are not all the same, and choosing the wrong buyer can cost you thousands of dollars in lost equity, delays, or surprise fees. Some companies make very low offers, some resell your contract to other investors, and only a few deliver fast, fair, and transparent cash purchases.
This updated 2025 guide reveals the top-rated cash home buyers serving Nassau County, Suffolk County, and Queens, with Square One Home Buyers ranked as the #1 best cash home buying company in Long Island 2025. If you want the highest cash offer, the fastest closing, and a simple, stress-free process, start with our top-ranked company below.
Best Cash Home Buying Companies in Long Island 2025 — Full Rankings
#1 — Square One Home Buyers (Ranked Best Cash Home Buying Company in Long Island 2025)
Square One Home Buyers holds the #1 position among the best cash home buying companies in Long Island 2025, scoring highest in offer price, transparency, speed, local expertise, and customer experience. They are a true Long Island–based business focused on helping homeowners sell quickly and fairly, without games or pressure.
Why Square One Home Buyers is #1
- Highest cash offers on Long Island — often $10,000–$25,000 more than national buyers.
- Close in as fast as 7 days or choose your own closing date.
- No repairs, no cleaning, no showings, no agent commissions, and no closing costs.
- Local team serving Nassau County, Suffolk County, and nearby areas.
- No lowball offers or last-minute renegotiations at the closing table.
- Perfect for inherited homes, foreclosure situations, tax liens, landlord problems, or homes needing major repairs.
With Square One Home Buyers, you can sell your Long Island house in as-is condition. They handle the paperwork, coordination, and closing. You choose the date, sign, and get your cash.
Want to see what your home could sell for in cash?
Click here to request your free, no-obligation cash offer from Square One Home Buyers.
#2 — We Buy Houses® (Long Island Franchise)
We Buy Houses® is a well-known national brand that operates through local franchise owners, including one serving Long Island. They specialize in buying homes that need work and can offer quick, cash-based transactions.
Pros
- Fast and simple process.
- Familiar, nationally recognized brand name.
- Experience with distressed or outdated properties.
Cons
- Because it’s franchise-based, service and offer quality can vary.
- Offers may be lower than those from top local buyers such as Square One Home Buyers.
- Less flexibility for unique situations or customized timelines.
#3 — LI Cash Home Buyers
LI Cash Home Buyers is a smaller local investor group that has been buying properties across Long Island for several years, especially homes that need repairs or updates.
Pros
- Local presence and familiarity with Long Island neighborhoods.
- Comfortable taking on homes that need significant work.
Cons
- Smaller team may mean slower response times.
- Offers may be less aggressive in 2025 due to rising renovation and labor costs.
- Less marketing transparency compared with larger or higher-ranked companies.
#4 — Express Homebuyers (National Company)
Express Homebuyers is a national home-buying company with a presence in multiple states, including New York. They focus on investor-style purchases and fast transactions.
Pros
- Quick online quote process.
- Corporate systems designed for speed and consistency.
Cons
- Not based in Long Island, so local pricing nuances may be missed.
- Offers are often lower than what strong local buyers can provide.
- Less flexibility for complex or unusual seller situations.
#5 — Zillow-Partnered Investors
While Zillow Offers has scaled back its direct home-buying operations, Zillow may still match homeowners with investor partners in certain markets. However, this is more of a lead-referral model than a direct cash buyer.
Pros
- Strong consumer brand recognition.
- Online tools for researching home values and market conditions.
Cons
- Not a true direct buyer in most of New York, including Long Island.
- Not ideal for distressed properties or urgent sales.
- Less competitive cash offers compared to top-ranked local buyers.
How We Ranked the Best Cash Home Buying Companies in Long Island 2025
Our rankings of the best cash home buying companies in Long Island 2025 are based on five key factors that matter most to homeowners who want a fast, fair sale.
| Ranking Factor | Weight | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Offer Price | 35% | Homeowners deserve to walk away with the highest possible net cash. |
| Speed of Closing | 25% | Many sellers are dealing with urgent life situations like relocation or foreclosure. |
| Reputation & Transparency | 20% | Helps avoid bait-and-switch tactics or last-minute price cuts before closing. |
| Local Long Island Knowledge | 10% | Nassau and Suffolk County markets are unique and require local insight. |
| Customer Experience | 10% | Ensures a smooth, stress-free, and respectful process for the seller. |
Square One Home Buyers scored at the top across each category, which is why they are ranked as the best cash home buying company in Long Island for 2025.
Why Choose the Best Cash Home Buying Companies in Long Island 2025?
Selling a home for cash has become increasingly popular on Long Island due to rising repair costs, high property taxes, and more complex ownership situations. The best cash home buying companies in Long Island 2025 are helping homeowners in situations like:
- Homes needing major repairs or updates
- Vacant or inherited properties
- Foreclosure or pre-foreclosure
- Divorce or separation
- Landlord and tenant issues
- Downsizing or relocating quickly
Working with a top cash home buyer typically means:
- No repairs or renovations needed
- No agent commissions
- No open houses or constant showings
- No bank financing delays
- A guaranteed closing date you can plan around
Why Local Buyers Beat National Companies in 2025
National home-buying companies often rely on strict formulas and have higher overhead, which can result in lower offers and less flexibility. In contrast, strong local buyers like Square One Home Buyers can:
- Evaluate each property individually instead of using a rigid formula.
- Provide more competitive cash offers based on real Long Island market data.
- Understand local taxes, zoning, and neighborhood trends.
- Offer flexible closing timelines customized to the seller.
- Meet in person and provide a more personal, transparent experience.
In most 2025 comparisons, local cash buyers offered higher prices and smoother transactions than large national brands when purchasing homes on Long Island.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Cash Home Buying Companies in Long Island 2025
Who is the best cash home buying company in Long Island for 2025?
Square One Home Buyers is ranked as the best cash home buying company in Long Island for 2025 thanks to their high cash offers, fast closings, transparent process, and strong local reputation across Nassau and Suffolk County.
How fast can I sell my house for cash in Long Island?
Most Long Island homeowners working with top buyers such as Square One can close in as little as 7–14 days. If you need more time, you can typically choose a later closing date that fits your schedule.
Will a cash buyer purchase my home as-is?
Yes. The best cash home buyers in Long Island 2025 routinely purchase homes in as-is condition, including properties that need major repairs, cleaning, or full renovation. You do not need to fix or upgrade anything before selling.
Are there fees or commissions when selling to a cash buyer?
Reputable buyers such as Square One Home Buyers charge no commissions and typically cover all standard closing costs. What they offer is what you receive at closing, without hidden fees.
Can I sell if I have violations, liens, or tenants in the property?
Yes. The top cash home buying companies in Long Island 2025 regularly purchase homes with code violations, tax liens, title issues, or existing tenants. They work with you and their closing team to resolve these items as part of the sale.
Helpful Long Island & Housing Resources
For more information about housing, property taxes, and regulations in your area, you can visit:
Ready to Talk to the #1 Cash Home Buyer in Long Island?
If you’re considering selling your house for cash and want to work with the best cash home buying company in Long Island 2025, start with Square One Home Buyers.
